Australian Idol 2 Winner

Last weeks show was a repeat of the second semi final show. The first contestant was great; then Dicko aboslutely crucified the next contestant....and it was all downhill from there. When Anthony , who had wowed them all the week before, got such scathing comments about his performance, the other contestants got nervous, and as each one stuffed up; the next one became more nervous and it was all downhill from there. I am not suggesting that the things Dicko says aren`t correct; but there has to be a better way to tell people...I don`t enjoy watching people get shattered/gutted. Courtney was just a diffrent person over the last few weeks, until he did well this week,thanks to his girfriends arrival.(he must feel so relieved; one can see it on his face) Marty was asked, "what has happened to you, you used to be so "..can`t think of the words used here, but they meant happy go lucky, a lot of fun. He was also asked why he was nervous, but said he wasn`t...he was then told that he could be seen shaking from where the judge was sitting.
What happened?? Dicko (and Mark) is what happened, I don`t think until this or was it last week?... that Dicko had a kind word to say to Marty...but there was never any advice on what "to do" , just what not to do...Marty was heard to comment weekly "I don`t know what they want from me"....Dicko commented to Mark about his obsession with Hayley....how in Marks eyes she couldn`t ever do a thing right..
So please Dicko, this post is meant to be constructive critisism........please find a way to get your message across without shattering these young peoples dreams. Aged in our 50`s we can`t wait for Sundays as these finalist are an abolutely amazing group of singers......hoping to buy the whole final series on DVD. If not available; at least a CD of all the group songs and the very best couple of songs from all singers. We voted in the finals last series, but afraid this time I just couldn`t pick a winner from the final 11.....they are all such an amazingly talented group of young people.

Christine » 15 October, 2004 9:10 AM

i totally think anthony is going to win . hes HOT and has a beautiful voice lol

donna » 8 November, 2004 7:40 PM

casey I hope you win because every time I hear you sing i feel it in my heart and it brings tears to my eyes. please if you ever can could you record the full version of that song Here where I stand , you sing it heaps better then tiffany. thankyou for giving me so much joy in watching idol

candy hurren » 9 November, 2004 2:09 AM

Casey i hope u win you are fantastic and a great vocalist.

phillip pease » 9 November, 2004 7:14 PM

Anthony 4 sure.

hi » 9 November, 2004 7:52 PM

Casey all da way, we need a chick idol!! isstead of a dude 1!!CHICKS all da way wooooooooooooooh!! u can do it casey, believe in urself!!

amy » 9 November, 2004 8:06 PM

LETS GO CASEY LETS GO! casey ur awesome ur the maddiest singer in australian idol! Bring back the win we love yah and beat anthony 4 me plz! and show those 13 yr old girls up.

phildo » 10 November, 2004 1:07 PM

hey Casy and Anthony i dont know how to send you seperate e-mails so ill just send the one. firstly Casey you are my absolute fave but i dont vote coz i dont have a mobile (as u may have guessed by then fact ive spelt your name 2 different ways in the 1 letter)i am 14 and i have been singing for 10 years now and no1 has inspierd me like u have. anthony u are so short id just like 2 say go the short ppl coz im shorter then u (but i am also alot younger)and ive noticed u have lil hands well i have the smalest hands in the skool so i no how u feel.mabey all italians and short with lil hands.hey u know wat i just realised do u ppl even read these? oh well i had fun writtin it
Good luch to the both of u.
Lots of Love
Bec (From Melbourne)

Rebecca » 11 November, 2004 10:08 PM

OMG CASEY IS SOOOOO HOT I WOULD PUT HER ON A DIET AND SHE WOULD BE STUNNING

» 16 November, 2004 11:55 AM